Competition Award Criteria
Award
|
Criteria |
Best of Show
Awarded to one entry per competition. Chosen from among Distinguished award recipients.
|
- Is the best of the best (chosen from among Distinguished entries).
- Approaches the "ideal" technical publication.
- Sets the standard.
- Provides a practically perfect integration of elements.
- Superior in all areas, incorporating all the principles of good writing and design.
- Exactly meets the audiences' needs.
- Shows innovation.
- Entry is eligible to continue to the international competition level.
|
|
| Distinguished |
- Clearly superior in all areas.
- Entry contains no major and few, if any, minor flaws.
- Entry shows outstanding application of good technical communications principles.
- Anticipates and fulfills the needs of its audience.
- Approaches the "ideal."
- Comments are confined to taste and style.
- Entry is eligible to continue to the international competition level.
- Entry is eligible to continue to the international competition level.
|
|
| Excellence |
- Consistently meets high standards in all areas.
- Clearly (if slightly imperfectly) displays exceptional understanding of good technical communications principles.
- Meets the audience's needs.
- Entry might contain a single major flaw or a few minor flaws.
- Comments are confined to taste and style, and minor suggestions.
|
|
| Merit |
- Consistently meets high standards in most areas.
- Displays good understanding of technical communications principles.
- Shows above-average proficiency.
- Meets the audience's needs.
- Entry might contain a small number of major flaws (1-2) or several minor flaws.
|